Robert Redford
Jay Gatsby
Mia Farrow
Daisy Buchanan
Bruce Dern
Tom Buchanan
Karen Black
Myrtle Wilson
Scott Wilson
George Wilson
Sam Waterston
Nick Carraway
Lois Chiles
Jordan Baker
Howard Da Silva
Meyer Wolfsheim
Roberts Blossom
Mr. Gatz
Edward Herrmann
Klipspringer
Elliott Sullivan
Wilson's Friend
Kathryn Leigh Scott
Catherine
Patsy Kensit
Pamela Buchanan
Norman Chancer
Detective at Pool
Regina Baff
Miss Baedeker
John Franchi
Photographer (uncredited)
Franklin Cover
Senator Evans (uncredited)
Brooke Adams
Party Guest (uncredited)
Mildred Shay
Party Guest (uncredited)
Tom Ewell
Mourner (uncredited)
Vincent Schiavelli
Thin Man (uncredited)
Arthur Hughes
Dog Vendor
Beth Porter
Mrs. McKee
Paul Tamarin
Mr. McKee
John Devlin
Gatsby's Bodyguard
Marjorie Wildes
Pamela's Nurse
Blain Fairman
Policeman
Bob Sherman
Detective at Pool
Janet Arters
A Twin at Gatsby Party
Louise Arters
A Twin at Gatsby Party
Sammy Smith
Comic
Ramon Gordon
Party Guest (uncredited)
Duncan Inches
Party Staffer (uncredited)
Nick Lucas
Singer (uncredited)
James Berwick
Reverend (uncredited)
Jerry Mayer
New York Journal Reporter (uncredited)
Robin Lebert
Party Guest (uncredited)