Jessica Chastain
Tammy Faye Bakker
Andrew Garfield
Jim Bakker
Cherry Jones
Rachel Grover
Vincent D'Onofrio
Jerry Falwell
Mark Wystrach
Gary Paxton
Sam Jaeger
Roe Messner
Louis Cancelmi
Richard Fletcher
Gabriel Olds
Pat Robertson
Fredric Lehne
Fred Grover
Chandler Head
Little Tammy Faye
Jay Huguley
Jimmy Swaggart
Michael MacCauley
Big Man
Coley Campany
DeDe Robertson
Wes Jetton
Male Nurse
Jess Weixler
Makeup Artist (voice)
Lindsay Ayliffe
Old Teacher (Bible College)
Kimberly Ann Parker
Reporter
Alan Boell
Stephen Chow
Randy Havens
Steve Pieters
Kelsi Chandler
PTL Patron
Joe Ando-Hirsh
Teenage Punk #1
Chris TC Edge
PTL Crew Member (uncredited)
Kyle Riggs
Jamie Charles Bakker (uncredited)
Alan Dale
Self (archive Footage)
Hugh Downs
Self (archive Footage)
Jay Leno
Self (archive Footage)
Ronald Reagan
Self (archive Footage)
Dan Johnson
Preacher
Grant Owens
Colonel Sanders
Craig Newkirk
Doctor
Maurie Speed
Nurse
Julie P. Tuggle
Pledge Lady
Dana Marks
True Believer
Lila Jane Meadows
Tammy Sue
Carolyn Mints
Wanda
Kelly Borgnis
PTL Patron
John Johnson
Teenage Punk #2
Grayson Carter
Teenage Punk #3
Callie Lipian
Jamie Charles Bakker (Baby)
Caroline Lipian
Tammy Sue Bakker (Baby)
Robert Bailey
Nashville Singer
Deb Thomas Cox
Nashville Singer
Ellen Dockery
Nashville Singer
Jana King Evans
Nashville Singer
Lee Hilliard
Nashville Singer
Mark Ivey
Nashville Singer
Michael B. Lusk
Nashville Singer
Craig Morris
Nashville Singer
Savannah Morris
Nashville Singer
Donna Rhodes
Nashville Singer
Kira Small
Nashville Singer
Allen Andrews
PTL Sax Player (uncredited)
Christian Goins
Little Danny
