Mark Popejoy
Mark
Julia Farrell
Julia
Cheyenne King
Aunt Cheyenne
Colby Coash
Mark's Father
Jason Bracht
Driver
Eric Moyer
DeFeo
Jennii Caroline
Jennii
Breana Mitchell
Breana
Daniel Joseph Stier
Dan (as Daniel Steir)
Tony Brown
Tony
Jade Michael LaFont
Jade
Britany Dailey
Brittany
Schuylar Craig
Schuylar
Jeanne Kern
Grandma
Jake Brokoven
Passenger
Emily Smith
DeFeo's Daughter
Sarah Moshman
TV Saleswoman