Jennifer Garner
Laura Pickler
Yara Shahidi
Destiny
Hugh Jackman
Boyd Bolton
Ty Burrell
Bob Pickler
Olivia Wilde
Brooke Swinkowski
Alicia Silverstone
Julie Emmet
Rob Corddry
Ethan Emmet
Ashley Greene
Kaitlen Pickler
Pruitt Taylor Vince
Ned Eaten
Kristen Schaal
Carol-Ann Stevenson
Phyllis Smith
Nancy
Joe Chrest
Butter Fan
Kelly Tippens
Mrs. Moore
Dodie Brown
June Carmichael
Mark Oliver
Martin Caswell
Corena Chase
Mrs. Schram
Jason Yudoff
Announcer
Andy Daly
Radio Announcer (voice)
Gavin Casalegno
Art Class Student (uncredited)
Gavin Casalegno
Art Class Student
Ted Ferguson
The Minister
Garrett Schenck
Orval Flanagan
Judy Leavell
Helen Flanagan
Deana Ricks
Butter Fan's Wife
Brett Hill
Hayden
Cindy Creekmore
Danielle Mattingly
Jeanne Evans
Mrs. Gunderson
Heather Cates
Laura's Fan (uncredited)
Christine Scheller
Transitional Home Worker
Michael C. 'Mike' Allen
Corporate Employee
Jennifer Benton
Car Buyer
Charlotte Biggs
State Fair Patron
Pearce Chadwick
Webelo
Keri Shahidi
Biological Mother
