Judy Greer
Grace Bradley
Pete Holmes
Bob Bradley
Molly Belle Wright
Beth Bradley
Lauren Graham
Narrator / Older Beth Bradley (voice)
Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez
Charlie Bradley
Matthew Lamb
Claude Herdman
Beatrice Schneider
Imogene Herdman
Lorelei Olivia Mote
Alice Wendleken
Danielle Hoetmer
Mrs. Wendleken
Kirk B.R. Woller
Reverend Hopkins
Elizabeth Tabish
Mrs. Grady
Vanessa Benavente
First Grade Teacher
Lauren Cochrane
Nurse Pond
Daina Leitold
Mrs. Hopkins
Jenni Burke
Ms. Graebner
Stephanie Sy
Mrs. Thomas
Tom Young
George Armstrong
Kynlee Heiman
Gladys Herdman
Ewan Wood
Leroy Herdman
Essek Moore
Ollie Herdman
Mason D Nelligan
Ralph Herdman
Wyatt Dewar
David
Nolan Grantham
Elmer Hopkins
Isla Verlot
Becky