Lacey Chabert
Cindy (voice)
Tahj Mowry
Ollie (voice)
Travis Tritt
Little Reindeer (voice)
Elizabeth Daily
Ted (voice)
John Forsythe
Mr. Ryan (voice)
Jess Harnell
Santa / Man #1 / Man #2 / Angry Man / Elves (voice)
Nell Carter
Mrs. Claus (voice)
Jeannie Elias
Little Girl/Old Woman/Little Boy/Boy/Mom/Young Woman (voice)
Randall Crissman
Singer (voice)
Scottie Haskell
Singer (voice)
Geoff Koch
Singer (voice)
Kellie Coffey
Singer (voice)
Scot Finch
Singer (voice)
Laura Lively
Singer (voice)
James W. Lively
Singer (voice)