Melissa Joan Hart
Sabrina / Sophie
Eddie Mills
Paul
Tara Strong
Gwen
Eric Alexander
Alberto
Nick Bakay
Salem Saberhagen (voice)
Richard Steven Horvitz
Stonehenge (voice)
Stefano Maria Mioni
Taxi Driver
Paolo Giovannucci
Statue of David
James Fields
Travis
Francesco Mazzini
Mercutio
Evelyn Furtak
Mrs. Guadagno
Robert Steiner
Roberto