Mary Martin
Annie Oakley
John Raitt
Frank Butler
Reta Shaw
Dolly Tate
Susan Luckey
Winnie Tate
Patricia Morrow
Jessie Oakley
Luke Halpin
Little Jake Oakley
John Eldredge
Foster Wilson
William O'Neal
Colonel 'Buffalo' Bill Cody
Donald Burr
Charlie Davenport
Norman Edwards
Tommy Keller
Zachary Charles
Chief Sitting Bull
Robert Nash
Gordon William 'Pawnee Bill' Lillie
Stuart Hodes
Wild Horse
Jan Skidmore
Nellie Oakley
Shelley Windsor
Little Girl
Robert Banas
Indian Dancer (uncredited)
Dennis Bonilla
Indian Twin (uncredited)
Thomas Bonilla
Indian Twin (uncredited)